Strategic Studies of Culture

Strategic Studies of Culture

Future research on cultural and art education policies in the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance On the 8-year horizon

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Candidate , Department of Cultural Management, Faculty of Management, Islamic Azad University, Kish International Branch,Iran Email:Rowshanaa77@gmail.com ORCID: 0009-0000-1063-4689
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Educational Management, Islamic Azad University, Roudehen Branch, Roudehen, Iran. ( Responsible author) zo.rashidi@iau.ac.ir ORCID: : 0000-0003-2769-8878
3 Assistant Professor, Industrial Design Department, Islamic Azad University, Yadegar Imam Branch, Tehran, Iran (ORCID: 0000-0002-6045-8908 AM.MADANI@IAUSR.AC.IR
Abstract
Introduction: Planning and policymaking at the level of social institutions require the identification of trends, changes, and macro-social transformations. In order to achieve the richness of science, education, culture, and art envisioned in the Twenty-Year Vision Document of the Islamic Republic of Iran, comprehensive frameworks have been developed. To design the path through which the country’s scientific and cultural development progresses from the current situation to the desired state, the Comprehensive Scientific Map of the Country and the Cultural Engineering Map of the Country have been formulated, approved, and announced with specific strategies. As a result of adopting a balanced view of scientific disciplines, universities, and cultural and artistic fields, Iran seeks to attain a superior position in science, education, and culture, and to establish scientism and science-centeredness as the dominant discourse across all areas of society.
Achieving these objectives requires future-oriented studies grounded in the vision document and the cultural engineering map, so that appropriate strategies and policies aligned with the desired future can be designed and formulated with foresight. The necessity of such studies becomes evident when considering that, in the current century, rapid technological advancements are accompanied by unavoidable social, cultural, and political changes. Futures studies provide a new and reliable tool for assessing and identifying these transformations.
The Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance is one of the governmental institutions responsible for implementing the “official policies of the Islamic Republic in the field of public culture,” understood as policies that are “planned, conscious, progressive, and excellence-oriented,” from the perspectives of policymakers, the media, and the public. A review of the Ministry’s current cultural and educational policies, as well as its past trends, indicates that major goals and approaches have been suspended or abandoned due to various factors, resulting in limited success in achieving the envisioned objectives. Practice-oriented methods, organizational structure, short-term perspectives, and event-driven approaches are among the key factors that have disrupted the Ministry’s policies and programs. Accordingly, examining these factors highlights the growing necessity of paying closer attention to future-oriented perspectives.
Method: Following a review of the research literature, 15 experts with relevant knowledge and experience were selected through judgmental and purposive sampling. Data were collected through a workshop session and a series of expert interviews. The interview findings were evaluated, validated, and refined through three rounds of the Delphi technique. Theoretical saturation was used as the criterion for terminating the sampling process. Through thematic analysis of the interview data, 31 variables were identified as drivers influencing this field. These drivers were subsequently subjected to structural analysis using MicMac software. In this stage, the direct and indirect influences and dependencies of the drivers were assessed and ranked. From among them, 10 key variables were entered into the Scenario Wizard software, leading to the identification of two scenarios with a high probability of occurrence.
Results: The first scenario for the future of the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance’s policies in the field of cultural and artistic education represents a more favorable situation. In this scenario, based on the country’s cultural engineering map, it is anticipated that the public will gain greater access to new art education technologies, including digital art education platforms, virtual reality, and the expanded use of artificial intelligence. To foster the development of cultural and artistic fields, the role of the private sector must be strengthened. This expanded role is reflected in increased support for artists, the growth in number and scope of art education centers, and the organization of cultural and artistic events.
Achieving the desired situation in art education policymaking also requires enhancing the country’s level of interaction within global communication networks. Public awareness of art, art education, and the social influence of art plays a critical role in realizing this scenario. Increased public awareness manifests in a stronger perceived need for diverse forms of art and a greater demand for participation in art education. One of the key drivers of this scenario is the reduction of a security-oriented approach to art. The dominance of such an approach restricts cultural and artistic activities to governmental institutions and leads to the adoption of ineffective administrative regulations. Another crucial driver is economic recovery, which, by reducing security-oriented perspectives toward art, enhances young people’s interest in artistic fields. According to the experts participating in this study, such conditions have been more observable in the cultural discourse of so-called reformist governments and merit further examination.
In contrast, the second scenario depicts an unfavorable situation for the expansion and promotion of art education policies. This scenario is characterized by neglect of economic conditions, the intensification of security-oriented views toward art and culture, the diminished role of artists and the private sector, and the continuation of existing trends in foreign relations and international interactions.
Discussion and Conclusion
 The mutual effects of the identified drivers were evaluated and analyzed using the Scenario Wizard software, resulting in the formulation of two scenarios with a high likelihood of occurrence. From the experts’ perspective, the first scenario presents a more desirable future for educational policies and policymaking within the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance. The second scenario reflects the persistence of the current situation and a trajectory of regression, representing an unfavorable outlook for art education policies in the country.
Keywords

Subjects


Alexa, A.C. (2021). Creative and Critical thinking in an Age of Complexity - Key Skills for Military Commanders. Land Forces Academy Review, 26, 87 - 92.
Barker, Chris.(2004) The Sage Dictionary of Cultural Studies. 
Bell, wendel (2003)foundations of future studies: History, purposes and knowledge: human science for a new era. Valume 1, London, transaction publishers.
Bayat, Majid and Janbaz, Dian (2011) Pathology of the foundations and process of cultural policy-making in the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran, Qoms. [In Persian]
Dwivedi,Y. K. Venkitachalam, K. Sharif, A. M. Al-Karaghouli, W. and Weerakkody, V. (2011). “Research trends in knowledge management: analyzing the past and predicting the future”. Inf. Syst. Manage. 28 (1), 43-5.
Fazeli, Nematollah and Ghlich, Morteza (2013) A New Approach to Cultural Policy, Cultural Policy from the Perspective of Cultural Studies, Tehran, Tisa Publications. [In Persian]
Ghadernejad Hamamian, Mehdi, Amani, Hamed and Aghaei, Abdullah (2014) Analysis of the Policies of the Cultural System of Contemporary Iranian Art with the Help of Max Weber’s Sociology of Religion (Case Study: Homa Gallery Approach), Quarterly Journal of Sociology of Culture and Art, 3(3), 62-44. HTTPS://DOI.ORG/10.34785/J016.2021.996. [In Persian]
Ghazî Nouri, Seyed Sepehr, Malekifar, Siavash, Ghanei-Rad, Mohammad Amin and Mousavi, Arash (2017) Identification and analysis of existing and desirable approaches in the country’s cultural industries based on the perspectives of stakeholders, Quarterly Journal of Strategic Studies of Public Policy, No. 26. [In Persian]
Guess, Raymond (2001). History and Illusion in Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hoshyar, Mehran (1999). Redefining Contemporary Iranian Handicrafts with a Futures Research Approach, Bi-Quarterly Journal of Iranian Industrial Arts, 5(1), 32-19. Doi: 10.22052/HSI.2022.246481.1030.[In Persian]
Mandi, Simon (2004) European Perspectives on Cultural Policy, Translated by: Hadi Ghobraei, Tehran, Cultural Research Office. [In Persian]
Milshina, Y., & Vishnevskiy, K. (2018). Potentials of collaborative foresight for SMEs. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 30(6): 701-717.
Orum Anthony (2001). Introduction to Political Sociology. University of Illinois at Chicago.
Rawelz, John (1996). Political Liberalism, New York, Colombia University Press
Research Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly (1999) Performing Arts Policies, Plans and Bills.[In Persian]
Sayadi, Mohammad and Nazemi Ardakani, Mehdi (2014) Studying the status of cultural economy components in Iran: Comparative comparison with selected countries in the world and presenting solutions for improving the status of the cultural economy in the country, Cultural and Social Strategy, 3(4).191-225. Doi: 20.1001.1.22517081.1393.3.4.7.4. [In Persian] 
The Seventh Five-Year Law of the Islamic Republic of Iran along with the general policies of the Seventh Plan with the priority of economic progress combined with justice (1403) Compiled by: Rasoul Rezaei, Tehran, Administrative Publishing House. ISBN: 3-1-91657-622-978. [In Persian]
The Cultural Engineering Map of the Country Approved by the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution (15/12/2012). [In Persian]
Wiener, M., Gattringer, R., & Strehl, F. (2020). Collaborative open foresight-A new approach for inspiring discontinuous and sustainability-oriented innovations. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 155(1): 119370.
Nahidi, Katrin (2023) The Cultural Politics of Art in Iran Modernism, Exhibitions, and Art Production, Cambridge University Press. 
Yazdi, Meysam (1999) Branding and Diplomacy of Contemporary Islamic Art, Issues and Methods of Key Actors in West Asia, Journal of Cultural Diplomacy, 2(1), 8-38.
Doi: 10.22034/CDRJ.2025.511250.1042.[In Persian]